BRINDI

"FREE BRINDI" This dog must not be euthanized!

Target:
The Honourable Judge Alanna Murphy, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia
Sponsored by: 
URGENT UPDATE MARCH 8, 2010

Brindi's fate will be decided on Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Brindi, a defenseless dog, has been incarcerated since July 24, 2008 in the SPCA kennels on Death Row in Halifax, Canada. Her fate hangs by a thread and is scheduled to be decided on Tuesday March 9, 2010 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She is  condemned to die for nothing other than just being a dog! Now, 1-year-7-months later, Canada is still intent on killing a defenseless dog and Brindi's time may be up.

Brindi's Crime?
She never attacked or threatened a person. She never killed or caused serious injury to a dog. Just a good natured mutt, 6-years-old, rescued from a shelter in 2007, by her owner, Francesca Rogier.

Brindi's Sentence?
On July 24, 2008, a few days after a minor encounter with another dog, animal control officers armed with a warrant and euthanization order, seized Brindi from her home without notice. She has now languished on Death Row, even after winning a landmark Supreme Court battle ordering the original euthanasia order null and void.   Yet, still and to date, the City of Halifax has spent over $417,000 on Brindi's detainment in refusing to release her. Unbelievably, Nova Scotia, Canada seems to be the first country ignoring its own Supreme Court Justice's ruling.

Animal Cruelty By a Government Agency
Brindi was confined indefinitely in a short term facility.  Recently, Brindi needed biopsy surgery of a suspected cancer growth found near her spine. Her teeth have deteriorated because she was denied her favourite "chew" toys and raw beef bones that her owner and friends brought to her on a regular basis.  She now suffers from painful and chronic pancreatitis due to the stressful conditions of her confinement. According to many, "It is concerning and distressing to think that this innocent and once healthy pet, has been detained and made to languish in isolation as pawns in political bureaucracy. She has been reduced to such poor physical state that it actually constitutes animal cruelty and neglect at its finest, and all at the hands of a governing agency."

Dangerous Dogs?
Experts have testified and reported that, "Regardless of the tremendous pain and isolation of her confinement, Brindi is still a friendly, well adjusted dog that poses no danger to the public in any way." Brindi has been evaluated as "not dangerous" and highly trainable. During eight weeks of obedience class, which she passed with ease, she had no issues with other dogs. Experts have testified her issues can be corrected with training and in no way constitutes a death warrant. Even after desperate attempts in creating public awareness and gaining public support and sympathy, creating petitions, informational videos, protests and massive email campaigns to government officials, candlelight vigils in worldwide support for Brindi's case, Canada has failed to compromise in a humane resolution of this precious dog.

According to many, "Speculation into corruption of government officials and growing questions as to what the true motivations are behind such a case. Brindi is just a dog, defenseless to man, that has done nothing wrong other than be born. Brindi, may be condemned to die after a few harmless dog squabbles. She is needlessly languishing and slowly deteriorating on a governments whim."

This brings to light some disturbing observations of some archaic and dangerous laws being practiced in the courts of Canada, where Brindi's case seems to lack in common sense, decency and most importantly, in humanity. Francesca Rogier,  Brindi's owner, is  financially devastated, as she fights a government to save the life of her dog. 

One can not help but wonder how such stories reach far and wide, no matter the nation, no matter where in the world and that it is only a matter of time before another "Brindi" reaches our own front doors, and it could be one of our dogs. Would we care then?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Public safety is an important responsibility of local government, as is the judicious use of force.  In Halifax, Nova Scotia, animal control authorities customarily employ pre-emptive euthanization, a needless and injurious loss of life.  

Brindi, a 5-year old mixed breed dog, has never bitten a person or seriously injured another dog. She is friendly and calm around people and likes the vast majority of dogs she meets. Found abandoned with 5 puppies, she waited 2 years in a shelter before owner Fracesca Rogier adopted her in 2007. Ms. Rogier had her microchipped, spayed and vaccinated. Brindi did very well in obedience class and obeys many commands. She loves her owner and is gentle and safe around infants, children and adults. She even lives peacefully with 2 cats.  

Brindi was charged with a total of three offences that were minor by any comparison. They happened when she accidentally got loose and ran up to dogs being walked along the road at her property line. Only the second offence resulted in an injury, a small tooth puncture requiring minimal vet care, for which Ms. Rogier voluntarily paid.  After this, the city issued a muzzle order. In Halifax By-Law A300, a muzzle order is one of six ways to deem a dog dangerous. The authorities construe this as a sanction for seizure and euthanization for any further violations. So, because she was not wearing her muzzle on the third offence, they seized her without warning four days later, even though the other dog was not grabbed or injured.

Brindi still remains incarcerated at the SPCA-run city pound, even though the Supreme Court quashed the euthanization order on January 16, 2009. HRM refuses to release her to her rightful owner, Francesca. She was allowed a brief visit with Brindi for the first and only time in late December 2008. This visit had to be held outside in the freezing cold and only lasted 25 minutes.  No further visits are permitted. 

This blanket imposition of the maximum penalty for minor offences is unjust. Halifax has already recognized that Brindi is not a threat to humans. It was informed by two respected trainers that her wayward behavior does not signify aggression and definitely can be corrected. Yet the city prefers to have her pay the ultimate price for human error, rather than accept reasonable alternatives that would both maintain safety and keep her alive.

Clearly, Brindi does not deserve to die. Furthermore, she contributes significantly to the health and well-being of her owner, Ms. Rogier, much as a seeing-eye dog helps the blind.  Ms. Rogier is desperate to have her precious dog back. She has already built fenced enclosures attached to her home entrances, engaged a private trainer and  offered to pay all fines and costs.

We strongly oppose the euthanization of Brindi. We appeal to HRM Animal Services and the City Council to accept Ms. Rogier's reasonable and responsible offer so that Brindi can go home immediately.
URGENT UPDATE MARCH 8, 2010

Brindi's fate will be decided on Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Brindi, a defenseless dog, has been incarcerated since July 24, 2008 in the SPCA kennels on Death Row in Halifax, Canada. Her fate hangs by a thread and is scheduled to be decided on Tuesday March 9, 2010 in Nova Scotia, Canada. She is  condemned to die for nothing other than just being a dog! Now, 1-year-7-months later, Canada is still intent on killing a defenseless dog and Brindi's time may be up.

Brindi's Crime?
She never attacked or threatened a person. She never killed or caused serious injury to a dog. Just a good natured mutt, 6-years-old, rescued from a shelter in 2007, by her owner, Francesca Rogier.

Brindi's Sentence?
On July 24, 2008, a few days after a minor encounter with another dog, animal control officers armed with a warrant and euthanization order, seized Brindi from her home without notice. She has now languished on Death Row, even after winning a landmark Supreme Court battle ordering the original euthanasia order null and void.   Yet, still and to date, the City of Halifax has spent over $417,000 on Brindi's detainment in refusing to release her. Unbelievably, Nova Scotia, Canada seems to be the first country ignoring its own Supreme Court Justice's ruling.

Animal Cruelty By a Government Agency
Brindi was confined indefinitely in a short term facility.  Recently, Brindi needed biopsy surgery of a suspected cancer growth found near her spine. Her teeth have deteriorated because she was denied her favourite "chew" toys and raw beef bones that her owner and friends brought to her on a regular basis.  She now suffers from painful and chronic pancreatitis due to the stressful conditions of her confinement. According to many, "It is concerning and distressing to think that this innocent and once healthy pet, has been detained and made to languish in isolation as pawns in political bureaucracy. She has been reduced to such poor physical state that it actually constitutes animal cruelty and neglect at its finest, and all at the hands of a governing agency."

Dangerous Dogs?
Experts have testified and reported that, "Regardless of the tremendous pain and isolation of her confinement, Brindi is still a friendly, well adjusted dog that poses no danger to the public in any way." Brindi has been evaluated as "not dangerous" and highly trainable. During eight weeks of obedience class, which she passed with ease, she had no issues with other dogs. Experts have testified her issues can be corrected with training and in no way constitutes a death warrant. Even after desperate attempts in creating public awareness and gaining public support and sympathy, creating petitions, informational videos, protests and massive email campaigns to government officials, candlelight vigils in worldwide support for Brindi's case, Canada has failed to compromise in a humane resolution of this precious dog.

According to many, "Speculation into corruption of government officials and growing questions as to what the true motivations are behind such a case. Brindi is just a dog, defenseless to man, that has done nothing wrong other than be born. Brindi, may be condemned to die after a few harmless dog squabbles. She is needlessly languishing and slowly deteriorating on a governments whim."

This brings to light some disturbing observations of some archaic and dangerous laws being practiced in the courts of Canada, where Brindi's case seems to lack in common sense, decency and most importantly, in humanity. Francesca Rogier,  Brindi's owner, is  financially devastated, as she fights a government to save the life of her dog. 

One can not help but wonder how such stories reach far and wide, no matter the nation, no matter where in the world and that it is only a matter of time before another "Brindi" reaches our own front doors, and it could be one of our dogs. Would we care then?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Public safety is an important responsibility of local government, as is the judicious use of force.  In Halifax, Nova Scotia, animal control authorities customarily employ pre-emptive euthanization, a needless and injurious loss of life.  

Brindi, a 5-year old mixed breed dog, has never bitten a person or seriously injured another dog. She is friendly and calm around people and likes the vast majority of dogs she meets. Found abandoned with 5 puppies, she waited 2 years in a shelter before owner Fracesca Rogier adopted her in 2007. Ms. Rogier had her microchipped, spayed and vaccinated. Brindi did very well in obedience class and obeys many commands. She loves her owner and is gentle and safe around infants, children and adults. She even lives peacefully with 2 cats.  

Brindi was charged with a total of three offences that were minor by any comparison. They happened when she accidentally got loose and ran up to dogs being walked along the road at her property line. Only the second offence resulted in an injury, a small tooth puncture requiring minimal vet care, for which Ms. Rogier voluntarily paid.  After this, the city issued a muzzle order. In Halifax By-Law A300, a muzzle order is one of six ways to deem a dog dangerous. The authorities construe this as a sanction for seizure and euthanization for any further violations. So, because she was not wearing her muzzle on the third offence, they seized her without warning four days later, even though the other dog was not grabbed or injured.

Brindi still remains incarcerated at the SPCA-run city pound, even though the Supreme Court quashed the euthanization order on January 16, 2009. HRM refuses to release her to her rightful owner, Francesca. She was allowed a brief visit with Brindi for the first and only time in late December 2008. This visit had to be held outside in the freezing cold and only lasted 25 minutes.  No further visits are permitted. 

This blanket imposition of the maximum penalty for minor offences is unjust. Halifax has already recognized that Brindi is not a threat to humans. It was informed by two respected trainers that her wayward behavior does not signify aggression and definitely can be corrected. Yet the city prefers to have her pay the ultimate price for human error, rather than accept reasonable alternatives that would both maintain safety and keep her alive.

Clearly, Brindi does not deserve to die. Furthermore, she contributes significantly to the health and well-being of her owner, Ms. Rogier, much as a seeing-eye dog helps the blind.  Ms. Rogier is desperate to have her precious dog back. She has already built fenced enclosures attached to her home entrances, engaged a private trainer and  offered to pay all fines and costs.

We strongly oppose the euthanization of Brindi. We appeal to HRM Animal Services and the City Council to accept Ms. Rogier's reasonable and responsible offer so that Brindi can go home immediately.

The Honourable Judge Alanna Murphy

Thousands of people from across the world, are pleading with you to uphold the original Supreme Court's decision not to euthanize Brindi and to return her to Francesca Rogier.

Brindi and Francesca have paid the price of human error and should not be punished any further.  

Thank you for saving Brindi's life.

signature
goal: 6,000
 
sign petition!
50
50 log in or sign up to start earning Butterfly Credits today!
Already a Care2 member? log in. Or, 
connect with Facebook
Name

optional
Email
Address
City
State
Province
Zip code Postal code

Increase your signature's impact by personalizing your letter


I agree to Care2's terms of service. We respect your privacy. Your email address is used to confirm your signature and is NOT displayed publicly.  
We signed the ""FREE BRINDI" This dog must not be euthanized!" petition!
# 6,007:
6:09 am PDT, Mar 16, Miriam Carneiro Saraiva, Brazil
# 6,006:
5:35 pm PDT, Mar 15, Barbara Clouse, South Carolina
I have been to Halifax many times and I always found the people of NS to be warm and friendly people. This is shocking that one little dog would be with held from her person for so long over such a trivial charge. It almost looks like someone has a vendetta against Brindi's owner. Please free this dog and let her go home.
# 6,005:
3:34 pm PDT, Mar 15, Ma. Elena Guillermo, Mexico
What is it with you government people in Canada? Can you not discern at all? I hope I am not too late to add my signature for Brindi's cause. A characteristic to the human race should be compassion but sometimes is the most scarce. What a shame!
# 6,004:
9:39 pm PDT, Mar 14, Name not displayed, Canada
Please leave this poor dog alone !! The owner abviously loves her pet and has initiated this petition to pressure authorities to do the right thing !!! It would be a crime to euthenize this person's pet !!
# 6,003:
7:13 pm PDT, Mar 14, Name not displayed, California
# 6,002:
6:53 pm PDT, Mar 14, Maria Eugenia Escobedo, Mexico
# 6,001:
3:03 pm PDT, Mar 14, Sigfrido Quijano, Canada
# 6,000:
3:12 am PDT, Mar 14, Didem Gokgoz, Turkey
# 5,999:
11:02 pm PST, Mar 13, Albert Pretorius, South Africa
# 5,998:
10:03 pm PST, Mar 13, Alyxandra Joy, Nevada
# 5,997:
2:21 pm PST, Mar 13, Tamara Wong, Canada
# 5,996:
6:30 am PST, Mar 13, Jennifer Rainey, Florida
I hope I am not too late. This is appalling! Criminals (often guilty) are afforded more rights treated better than this poor (innocent) animal.
# 5,995:
5:56 am PST, Mar 13, Yavuz Özaslantaş, Turkey
# 5,994:
2:12 am PST, Mar 13, Sabine Brandmaier, Austria
# 5,993:
3:24 pm PST, Mar 12, Saundra Harris, Arizona
# 5,992:
1:08 pm PST, Mar 12, Kristina Aldoshina, Russian Federation
# 5,991:
12:31 pm PST, Mar 12, Dr Callahan, Washington
# 5,990:
9:15 am PST, Mar 12, Name not displayed, Ohio
# 5,989:
7:28 am PST, Mar 12, Eva Hoerler, California
Please send Brindi home to her loving adopted mother who misses her so badly and is fighting so hard to get her home!!!
# 5,988:
1:42 am PST, Mar 12, Sue Lesmond, Australia
I am absoultely appaulled by Canadas treatment of Brindi and thepoor seals. What is wrong with you Canada. You were once my favourite long haul overseas travel destination. Not anymore. How dare you treat this beautiful dog like this. Let it go back to its owner you moronic Canadian Government. Get civilised
# 5,987:
10:06 pm PST, Mar 11, Barbara Daskal, Pennsylvania
To the City of Halifax. As an owner of 2 dogs, who run our property, I am asking you to set Brindi free. Brindi was only defending herself within the limits of her owners property. She did not hurt anyone, as far as I am concerned. Why weren't the people of the other dogs charged in this case for allowing their dogs to run off leash? Don't you think a dog has the right to defend itself on its owners' property? I think a law should be in place for owners of dogs to leash their dogs when they are off property. Our 2 dogs run off leash within our property line, thanks to an electric fence. When off the property, they are leashed. The owners of the other dogs in the Brindi case, should have had their dogs leashed. Brindi was only being a dog, nothing more. She is not dangerous, and should be allowed to go hom e with her owner. It is UNFAIR to go to this length in this case. The City of Halifax looks like it is scapegoating Brindi and her owner. Find more important things to do with the taxpayers money. This woman and her dog have paid more than is necessary. The City of Halifax should be ashamed of itself for targeting this woman and her dog.

RR7 Box 1258 Saylorsburg, Pa 18353

# 5,986:
8:14 pm PST, Mar 11, Kathy Cassidy, Canada
# 5,985:
4:07 pm PST, Mar 11, Irene Krizek, New York
# 5,984:
3:08 pm PST, Mar 11, Mike Downs, Missouri
# 5,983:
2:57 pm PST, Mar 11, Esin ALPTÜRK, Turkey
# 5,982:
1:25 pm PST, Mar 11, Ruth S., Germany
# 5,981:
11:09 am PST, Mar 11, Canan Apari, Turkey
# 5,980:
9:55 am PST, Mar 11, Holger Herb, Germany
# 5,979:
9:54 am PST, Mar 11, Silke Herb, Germany
# 5,978:
9:35 am PST, Mar 11, Semra çetinsoy, Turkey
# 5,977:
9:15 am PST, Mar 11, Cyrielle TRAVAGLINI, France
# 5,976:
8:39 am PST, Mar 11, Lindsay LeGault, Canada
Save the dog! 336 York Street Cornwall, Ontario K6H 3Z3
# 5,975:
8:00 am PST, Mar 11, Mary Antoine, Florida
# 5,974:
3:32 am PST, Mar 11, Firdaus Salleh, Malaysia
# 5,973:
2:54 am PST, Mar 11, Kemal Pulgu, Turkey
# 5,972:
12:22 am PST, Mar 11, Naiad Rivero, Spain
# 5,971:
11:13 pm PST, Mar 10, Sibel Öğretir, Turkey
Brindi must be free.
# 5,970:
11:06 pm PST, Mar 10, Paula Strzemecka, Poland
# 5,969:
5:46 pm PST, Mar 10, Eli Suarez, Massachusetts
# 5,968:
5:21 pm PST, Mar 10, Ana Ramos, California
# 5,967:
4:50 pm PST, Mar 10, Michele Jones, Pennsylvania
# 5,966:
4:19 pm PST, Mar 10, Patricia Cannell, Canada
# 5,965:
4:19 pm PST, Mar 10, Dorothy Steed, Alabama
# 5,964:
3:05 pm PST, Mar 10, Carl E. French, Canada
This situation is totally untenable in my mind. The resources expended on a case involving an animal who was felt he needed to protect his owner from other animals on his property is totally ridiculous. Animals are the best form of security for a single person or family and the city of Halifax has blown it immensely. Brindi should be release immediately and the city should bear the cost of boarding him as punishment for keeping him from his owner. May God bless Brindi and give the city of Halifax some smarts. Amen
# 5,963:
2:30 pm PST, Mar 10, Nazire Ergun, Turkey
# 5,962:
1:59 pm PST, Mar 10, Joyce Micaleff, Italy
WHYYYYYYYYY ALL THIS CRUELTY????????? ARE WE GOD ???? CAN WE DECIDE ON LIFE OR DEATH???????? PLEASE, PLEASE LETBRINDI FREE , LET HER GO BACK HOME

Joyce Micaleff Via S. ignazio 11 00186 Rome, Italy josephine.m@libero.it

# 5,961:
1:26 pm PST, Mar 10, Name not displayed, Florida
# 5,960:
1:18 pm PST, Mar 10, Idil Soysal, Turkey
# 5,959:
1:06 pm PST, Mar 10, Nancy Poopatanapong, California
# 5,958:
9:53 am PST, Mar 10, Ana Bulnes, Vermont
# 5,957:
7:23 am PST, Mar 10, Teresa Richardson, Canada
# 5,956:
7:13 am PST, Mar 10, Gunseli Tumer, Netherlands
jan van zutphenstr 783
# 5,955:
6:37 am PST, Mar 10, Kate Brilly, United Kingdom
release brindi from this nightmare she is not a dangerous dog !!!!
# 5,954:
6:36 am PST, Mar 10, Seda Yavuz, Turkey
# 5,953:
6:20 am PST, Mar 10, Alexandra Sonja Van Bergen, Ireland
# 5,952:
6:20 am PST, Mar 10, Sheryl Belletti, United Kingdom
Copyright © 2010 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved