It has been rumored that the two top contenders for the part of Leah Clearwater in New Moon are 2 Disney stars: Vanessa Hudgens and Brenda Song. I think these are two AWFUL picks for Leah. First of all, Vanessa Hudgens already had her star moment: in all the HSM movies. Give someone else a chance! Second of all, I highly doubt her ability to play a serious part such as Leah's. And Brenda Song? She's Thai/Chinese while Leah is Native American. And as a HUGE Twilight fan, I say we gotta stay true to the book. Please sign this petition and HELP!!!!!
It has been rumored that the two top contenders for the part of Leah Clearwater in New Moon are 2 Disney stars: Vanessa Hudgens and Brenda Song. I think these are two AWFUL picks for Leah. First of all, Vanessa Hudgens already had her star moment: in all the HSM movies. Give someone else a chance! Second of all, I highly doubt her ability to play a serious part such as Leah's. And Brenda Song? She's Thai/Chinese while Leah is Native American. And as a HUGE Twilight fan, I say we gotta stay true to the book. Please sign this petition and HELP!!!!!
We signed the "Vanessa Hudgens as Leah Clearwater in New Moon? I vote NO WAYY!!!" petition!
# 640:
4:15 pm PDT, Jul 4,Name not displayed, North Dakota
My sister Ta'Sheena Finn who is very Native American, is way better than the Disney girls. Her name means warmth in Lakota and she is very pretty. Check her out.
# 639:
1:37 pm PDT, Jul 4,Kate Harp, Minnesota
V. Hudgens will give me another reason to cry during this depressing movie...her lack of talent. She is fine for disney movies, because disney actors are a joke. But this movie deserves someone who can deliver, and vanessa can't.
# 638:
2:24 am PDT, Jul 3,Ashley Someone, California
Great! Now we have a horrible actress to ruin the movie! Hope she isnt in it!
# 637:
8:35 am PDT, Jun 29,Jade Dogan, United Kingdom
NO! This can't be allowed, I will refuse to watch the movie, and many of my friends have said the same.
Vannessa Hugdens ESPECIALLY will DESTROY the magic behind Eclipse! :'(
# 636:
10:31 am PDT, Jun 28,Lindsey Bailey, Indiana
i agree that neither could play the role i think somone else should do it somone that has more talent playing a serious tough role
# 635:
5:39 pm PDT, Jun 21,Name not displayed, Australia
I believe,seeing i luv twilight that vanessa hudgens as leah would be a huge mistake.
# 634:
5:26 pm PDT, Jun 21,Daniella Cullen, Venezuela
i just have to say one thing..NO NO NO!! those girls sucks!! they do not have what it takes to be in a twilight saga...besides i hate them!! i think they are part of the "whore club" i just say no way!!!
plus, the new director of new moon (Chris Weitz) has to know what are the characters in good conditions to be part of this terrific saga! i still cant belive it..! this cant be! nonoonononononooo!! plus..! c'mon! Disnay?? the subliminal Disney?? ON NEW MOON? not combined for me, disney sucks in this kind of movies!
# 633:
5:19 am PDT, Jun 16,Louise Quinn, United Kingdom
Both of them are not right for the role, its not simply because Vanessa has had the limelight before or has done hsm, it would be stupid to exclude her from a role because of that, she has not got the right look for Leah, Leah is a strong, tall, dark haired and somewhat dark skinned character and there are many other people who are more suited to this role. Brenda is also not right for the reasons specified in the petition.
# 632:
6:51 pm PDT, Jun 15,Rhia Buckley, Ireland
this girl is a preppy disney twilight wannabe n it cant happen it would wreck the movie completely
# 631:
1:20 pm PDT, Jun 14,Megan Hails, United Kingdom
she is a great actor and would be great as leah
# 630:
5:58 am PDT, Jun 11,Sofie Nielsen, Denmark
Vanessa Hudgens is Disney star for crying out loud! She is totally gonna ruin the whole movie if she plays Leah Clear water. And Brenda Song is also a Disney star. Find a unknown female to play the role please! and a god one.
# 629:
9:36 am PDT, Jun 6,Millaray Aburto Montoya, United Kingdom
For more impact, add a personal comment here
# 628:
6:42 am PDT, Jun 5,Nina Malin, Finland
# 627:
6:00 am PDT, Jun 5,Name not displayed, Finland
If Vanessa gets cast as Leah, it's gonna ruin the whole movie. A HSM star in Twilight? NO. Hope they get someone who can play Leah and be BELIEVABLE. -.-
# 626:
4:14 am PDT, Jun 5,Name not displayed, Australia
i think vanessa hudgens wouldn't be bitchy eenough to be leah and couldn't put up a bad girl rough tough image. You also can't have a wolf be prettier than the main charator.
# 625:
3:12 pm PDT, Jun 2,Name not displayed, Florida
I will never allow this to happen!!!! i am signing every petition online!!!!
# 624:
10:05 pm PDT, Jun 1,Name not displayed, Mississippi
no way bcuz a while back she took dirty pics of herself for......drake bell not zac but zac found them and posted them on the internet for revenge.cuz she made love with drake so i say id rather let brenda play leah hey at least it would be way better than a stuty horey bitch!!! and you got to admit that!! and i think that a real native or someone a little native should play leah(like me jus kiddin id play for jacob and edward!but i really am a native american cuz my great grandad wuz a cheif like no lie jus sayin:) you know cuz edward and jacob are SEXY BEASTS LOL) so you know my vote its ......... HELL NO!!!!!
PEACE LOVE YA GOD BLESS!!! AND REMEBER... PEACE,LOVE,& TWILIGHT!!!!!!!! LATA IM OUT!!!!!!!!
# 623:
7:48 pm PDT, May 17,Mia Norris, Michigan
Ican't stand her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
# 622:
9:45 am PDT, May 16,Sabrina Bajwa, Canada
OMFG no no no no no....
# 621:
12:47 pm PDT, May 12,Name not displayed, Michigan
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO VANESSA CAN NOT BE LEAH CLEARWATER I HATE HER SOO MUCH!!!!!!! SHE'S A POOP HEAD! SHE IS DATING THE PERSON I LOVE!.......SHE IS SOOO STUPID! UGH! IF SHE IS I AM SOO NOT WATCHING THE MOVIE...(OKAY MAYBE I WILL BUT STILL I HATE HER EVERYONE DOES AND NO ONE LIKES HER!) GRRRRRR AND I CAN NOT SEE HER BRING A WEREWOLF! AND EVERYONE WILL THINK THAT IT IS DISNEY SO NO NONONONONO! A MILLION TIMES NO!
# 620:
4:33 am PDT, May 12,Jessica Rathgeber, United Kingdom
NO WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
# 619:
2:19 pm PDT, May 8,James Daffy, Montana
this is stupid why would vanessa or brenda ever play leah?? the only reason they want to be in it is either to get to rob or to become more famous...either one isn't happening so they can just stay out of twilight.
# 618:
11:11 am PDT, May 7,Caitlin Hale, United Kingdom
NO WAY I HATE VANESSA HUDGENS AND I AM A REAL HALE AND I REALY DONT WANT A DISNEY w**re P:LAYING A GOOD GUY SHES HAD HER DAY :@
# 617:
5:43 pm PDT, Apr 30,Jayce Hughs, Illinois
no way can she live up to this role!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ever
# 616:
7:06 pm PDT, Apr 22,Name not displayed, New York
# 615:
8:25 pm PDT, Apr 17,Name not displayed, Canada
i say NO to vanessa hudgens. she'll just ruin the movie!
# 614:
8:31 am PDT, Apr 15,Cassie Ponce, Canada
EEWWWW.....
no friggin way!!!!!!!!!!!
NNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
# 613:
2:17 pm PDT, Apr 14,Ashley Seath, Canada
5 reasons:
1.in all her movies she plays the helpless victim of something who ur supposed to feel bad for, while leah is supposed to be tough.
2.she isnt native american
3.she cant act
4.shes a disney actor, which means that she is more well suited for roles that appeal to children
5.i hate her >:(
# 612:
11:12 am PDT, Apr 14,Jadell Hawks, North Carolina
No Way! Neither have strong Native American descent and that is an insult. There are a wide variet of girls and these two do not fit the part. No Way!
# 611:
4:44 pm PDT, Apr 13,Name not displayed, Florida
# 610:
2:55 pm PDT, Apr 13,Name not displayed, Michigan
# 609:
12:43 pm PDT, Apr 12,Christina Benson, Maryland
NO TO VANESSA HUDGENS !!!!!
# 608:
1:24 pm PDT, Apr 5,Name not displayed, California
# 607:
2:19 am PDT, Mar 26,Regina Bottoms, Arizona
# 606:
10:57 pm PDT, Mar 23,Taylor K, Australia
no way she can get stuffed! give someone else a chance
# 605:
7:12 pm PDT, Mar 22,Name not displayed, Canada
vanessa hudgens should not be leah clearwater. the impact of her character would be better played as someone who is not the face of a famous movie franchise.
# 604:
9:52 am PDT, Mar 21,Lauren Glenn, Virginia
In all honesty, the movie twilight wasn't as good as it could've been. They still have a chance to redeem themselves but if you cast either of those girls, the series will lose money at the box office. It'll be better to find a no name, vanessa has ruined her rep by the choices she has made and there are a lot of people who would be very dissappointed
# 603:
8:34 pm PDT, Mar 18,Daniela Barajas, California
i dont think Vanessa Hudgens or Brenda song should get the part of leah clearwater because neither of them are native american and there both to innocent to by a werewolf!!!1
# 602:
1:10 pm PDT, Mar 17,Rachel H, Maryland
Vanessa Hudgens as LEAH CLEARWATER?! NO WAY!!!!!!!!!!! And Brenda Song? Really. They must be either crazy or really desperate for a young actor that can "relate" to the younger audience, such as myself. I love twilight a lot [I read all four books] and seeing Brenda or Vanessa on the screen as Leah in New Moon would make the movie much, MUCH less enjoyable.
# 601:
12:58 pm PDT, Mar 17,KATLIN DITTO, California
never put a hsm PERSON in TWILGHT NEVER!!!!!