Dear Prudence: Stop Telling People to Put Down Healthy Cats!

  • by: Carole M.
  • recipient: Emily Yoffe, Dear Prudence Columnist, Slate.com

Slate.com's popular Dear Prudence advice columnist, Emily Yoffe, recently advised a reader to put down a healthy 18-year-old cat because its owner finds the cat too expensive and a nuisance.  Sign the petition to tell Ms. Yoffe to apologize for telling people to put down their healthy pets and never to offer such advice again!

In the column, a reader writes that their elderly cat costs $200/month in care and howls at her at night to feed her. The person writes:

"When I talked to the vet about putting her to sleep, they said she is a healthy animal with manageable concerns and that they would not do that. She is friendly and alert but she is ruining my life."

Ms. Yoffe responds by telling the writer to put the cat down even though the cat is not suffering:

"Of course your vet won’t put down Fluffy; she’s a gold mine. But you can take her to the nearest humane society shelter. When you explain she’s 18, deaf, toothless, and has a host of medical conditions, they will break out the Fatal-Plus. You explain to your kids that you have loved Fluffy since before they were born, but she is very old and sick now—she can’t sleep at night, she is going downhill, and you don’t want her to suffer. (OK, maybe she’s not suffering, but you are.)"

Please sign the petition to tell Ms. Yoffe to apologize for telling people to put down their healthy pets and never to offer such advice again!

Update #19 years ago
Thanks for signing -- there's one more way you can help this cat! Please consider donating to the GoFundMe of the family struggling to care for the needy cat. (Care2 has verified this GoFundMe fundraiser is in fact owned by the woman featured in the Dear Prudence column). Click here or copy & paste in your browser --> http://www.gofundme.com/oldcatdearprudence
Sign Petition
Sign Petition
You have JavaScript disabled. Without it, our site might not function properly.

Privacy Policy

By signing, you accept Care2's Terms of Service.
You can unsub at any time here.

Having problems signing this? Let us know.