Care2 member? Log in

Let Safeway know you won't buy farmed salmon!

Target: Stephen Burd, Chairman, President and CEO, Safeway
Sponsored by: Coastal Alliance for Aquaculture Reform (CAAR)
Farmed salmon raises human health concerns and also environmental risks

Human Health Concerns
In what is considered the most thorough analysis of farmed and wild salmon to date, a study released in the respected journal Science in January 2004 found that, in most cases, consuming more than one serving of farmed salmon per month could pose unacceptable cancer risks, according to United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standards for determining safe fish consumption levels.

Environmental Risks
Recent research published in the internationally renowned Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences revealed that the number of sea lice on young wild salmon is higher in areas near salmon farms. The report demonstrated a link between sea lice from fish farms and the decline of certain wild salmon stocks in Canada's Pacific Ocean.

Salmon farming poses risks of disease transfer to wild fish and escapes of farmed salmon into the wild. Waste from the farms including antibiotics, pesticides and harmful chemicals are released into the ocean. Often fish farms are located directly in areas where First Nations or other communities object.

In light of these concerns and recent findings, it is difficult to understand how major retailers like Safeway continue to stock farmed salmon. If you care about your health and the environment, please sign this petition to send a free fax to Safeway. Tell Safeway that you won't buy farmed salmon until these health and environmental concerns have been met!
deadline: 5-3-2005
goal: 4,000
 

Sign Petition!  see who signed this
log in

This petition has been closed.

see more petitions

Dear Mr. Burd,

I am writing to express my concern over the sale of farmed salmon at Safeway. A study published this January in the respected journal Science found that, in most cases, consuming more than one serving of farmed salmon per month could pose unacceptable cancer risks, according to the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standards for determining safe fish consumption levels.

[Your comments: State your concerns over the health impacts of farmed salmon]

In light of these results, I urge you to act in the best interest of your customers and remove farmed salmon from your stores. Healthy and sustainable seafood alternatives to farmed salmon, such as wild salmon or halibut, are available and I ask that you offer these products instead of farmed salmon.

[Your comments: Discuss why Safeway should not sell farmed salmon]

I will only purchase farmed salmon from companies that use farming practices and technology that: Eliminate the risk of disease transfer to wild fish and escapes of salmon into the wild; Prevent fish farm waste from being released into the ocean; Label all farmed fish so consumers can make informed choices; Use fish feed that does not result in a global loss of seafood for human consumption; Use fish feed that does not result in unsafe levels of contaminates in farmed salmon; Ensure that wildlife is not harmed as a result of fish farming; prohibit the use of genetically modified fish; eliminate the use of antibiotics, biocides and harmful chemicals in fish farming; respect the views of coastal residents and do not locate farms where First Nations or other communities object.

I will not buy farmed salmon from Safeway until the many health and environmental problems have been solved. I would appreciate and expect a reply to my concerns.

Sincerely,
We signed the “Let Safeway know you won't buy farmed salmon!” petition!
# 4,400:
6:50 am PDT, Jun 21, Carrie Abel, Louisiana
I am concerned the levels of toxicity are so high in the farmed salmon that you would be risking cancer by eating it only once a month!!

The Safeway company is focused solely on their own profit rather than the safety of their customers.

# 4,399:
6:33 am PDT, Jun 21, Amy Emerhi, New York
Farmed salmon causes cancer.

Because farmed salmon causes cancer.

# 4,398:
4:25 am PDT, Jun 21, Dotty Haas, Pennsylvania
Too many cemicals.

A danger to your health.

# 4,397:
1:56 am PDT, Jun 21, Giovanna Motta, Italy
Stop farming salmon.

It's like poisoning we eaters...and other fishes,too!

# 4,396:
1:20 am PDT, Jun 21, Christine Kasten, Arizona
There is evidence to support concern.

If there is evidence to indicate cancer risks with farmed salmon, Safeway should not be selling it.

# 4,395:
12:13 am PDT, Jun 21, Charlene Pratt, California
Let's stop messing with the natural order of life. All we succeed in doing is making an un-natural mess.

Aren't there enough risks in the world to our health without your adding more? A responsible food chain should care about its customers. That's the best way to keep the old ones and get new ones.

# 4,394:
11:28 pm PDT, Jun 20, Nina L. Dabbieri, California
Possible side effects.

Possible side effects to both human and wildlife.

# 4,393:
11:03 pm PDT, Jun 20, Fw Cooper, Colorado
There is more then enough evidance to warrant this concern.

AS a provider of part of the nations food supply is within your responsibility to adhere to safety and health concerns of all of your customer so do so.

# 4,392:
10:41 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
It's unhealthy.

Why sell something unhealthy just to make a profit?

# 4,391:
10:22 pm PDT, Jun 20, Christian Resch, Austria
-.

-.

# 4,390:
10:12 pm PDT, Jun 20, Candice Silsby, California
Salmon farming devastates the enviornment and poses a serious threat to wild salmon. Please support sustainable fishing.

Supporting this industry puts customers health in jeprody and our enviornment.

# 4,389:
8:53 pm PDT, Jun 20, Shirley Brim, California
There is ample clear evidence of the detrimental health effects of the coloring used to give farmed salmon its characteristic color. Why would i intentionally expose myself to this risk?

There should be no need to offer any other reason for Safeway to IMMEDIATELY discontinue selling ALL farmed salmon. Any failure to do so is clear evidence of Safeway's lack of concern for the well-being of it customers.

# 4,388:
7:55 pm PDT, Jun 20, Yohanan Assefa, California
They produce a lot of waste and aren't that healthy.

Portect the environment.

# 4,387:
7:20 pm PDT, Jun 20, Laurel Campbell, Massachusetts
Research has shown that the risks of consuming farmed salmon far outweigh any benefits, and the risks extend to wild salmon, to the earth. It is a very dangerous practice and should be discontinued immediately.

Health reasons-- for people, for the salmon, for the earth. I refuse to buy or consume any farmed salmon and I frequently discuss it with my friends. Actually, I discuss it with strangers when the opportunity presents itself!

# 4,386:
7:13 pm PDT, Jun 20, Marca Leigh, New Jersey
It isnt healthy to eat & its not fair to the salmon.

See above.

# 4,385:
6:49 pm PDT, Jun 20, Jennifer Boisvert, Alaska
We should manage our resources responsibly not try to replace them with dangerous alternatives.

It is not healthy for people or our economy and is destroying our natural fisheries.

# 4,384:
6:32 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
Farmed raised salmon dilute the genetics of the native Pacific salmon. Some have escaped from fish farms in the Pacific Northwest and established breeding populations in British COlumbia. This could be a disaster for native populations.

Selling farmed salmon encourages bad practices in the fishing community.

# 4,383:
6:28 pm PDT, Jun 20, Jennifer Mowery, Ohio
Raised in small areas and possilbe chemicals used.

Read above.

# 4,382:
6:24 pm PDT, Jun 20, William Peltz, New York
Salmon is one of my staple foods - but now I will be more careful, as I consume much more than the recommended "dosage" of farmed salmon.

Unsafe products shouldn't be marketed.

# 4,381:
5:39 pm PDT, Jun 20, Dillon Lewis, Canada
SPREAD OF CANCER.

CONTROL THE SPREAD OF CANCER.

# 4,380:
5:26 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
I believe that our food should not be tampered with.

Please make a statement that you will not stand for farmed salmon that will impact the environment.

# 4,379:
5:02 pm PDT, Jun 20, Jody Gray, Oregon
I am very concerned about what I eat and drink...You are what you eat !! There is so much junk added to so much of our food..That I try very hard to controll what I can......

I will not buy it, and I will tell all my friends.....

# 4,378:
4:15 pm PDT, Jun 20, ROBYN BLECHLE, Illinois
ITS JUST WEIRD NOT NEAT.

WEIRD NOT NEAT NOT MANY GOOD THINGS.

# 4,377:
4:12 pm PDT, Jun 20, Linda Vail, Washington
Farming salmon unacceptable becouse of health and concerns and is enviormentaly unsound.

As a long time Safeway shopper, I would very much like to be able to buy healthy food when I shop. I cannot buy farmed salmon,please do not sell this fish.

# 4,376:
3:37 pm PDT, Jun 20, Sandy Rusch, Illinois
Farmed salmon is not healthy so I will not purchase it.

I would think Safeway would want to only sell SAFE food to their consumers!

# 4,375:
3:10 pm PDT, Jun 20, Elizabeth Hurwitz, Michigan
Safeway should promote the health of its customers, as well as promoting spending by its customers, in its stores.

Farmed salmon is not safe for children and adults to consume on a regular basis. Safeway should put greater emphasis on promoting safe and healthful food for its customers to purchase.

# 4,374:
3:09 pm PDT, Jun 20, Paul Filiault, Massachusetts
I will not buy farmed fish of any kind.

Because fresh wild fish are the only healthy variety.

# 4,373:
2:35 pm PDT, Jun 20, Jennifer Grant, Canada
Salmon farms pollute coastal waters and can spread parasites and diseases to wild salmon populations.

Farmed salmon contains much higher levels of contaminants (PCBs that are linked to increased rates of cancer and birth defects) than wild salmon. Please give people the choice to pollute themselves and sell wild salmon!

# 4,372:
1:57 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, Brazil
Fish should be healyh food for us and the ocean...

There's no Safeway where I live, but if it's name is "safe"way, it should sell safe products...

# 4,371:
1:48 pm PDT, Jun 20, Brian Dalton, Spain
Fattier, clogging arteries. Comparatively tasteless.

Meat of various kinds, fish: both bred to be killed to satisfy humans.

# 4,370:
1:41 pm PDT, Jun 20, Cheri Collins, California
Farming pollutes the environment and endangers the wild population.

I will never buy it.

# 4,369:
1:39 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, United Kingdom
You risk transfering diseases to the wild fish and polluting the waters with your dumping of the pestersides and antibiotcs you use.

For the reasons stated above and who wants to eat the fish which have been exposed to the pestersides an antibiotics anyway!

# 4,368:
1:30 pm PDT, Jun 20, Vanessa Galliano, Louisiana
Safe food source.

Safety.

# 4,367:
12:53 pm PDT, Jun 20, Sheri Washington, Virginia
I dont know.

I dont know.

# 4,366:
12:32 pm PDT, Jun 20, Nicole Preece, Idaho
Society needs to be safe from the impacts of farmed salmon.

It is harmful to societies health.

# 4,365:
12:27 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
No Thanks.

No Thanks.

# 4,364:
12:25 pm PDT, Jun 20, Stefan Kraft, Germany
Fish is considered to be a healthy food. In fact, it would be if there weren't the problems presented by this petition.

For the health of its costumers and the environment.

# 4,363:
12:16 pm PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, Florida
Same as ABOVE.

Safeway SHOULD ALSO BE more RESPONSIBLE to IT's CUSTOMERS, re: SAFE FOOD PRODUCTS sold.

# 4,362:
11:27 am PDT, Jun 20, Kristen Nowicki, Florida
People think they are doing good by eating farmed salmon but do not realize the risks to health and the environment.

(There is no Safeway in my area).

# 4,361:
11:19 am PDT, Jun 20, Michelle Hoffee, California
Byproduts...

Poisious byproducts.

# 4,360:
11:15 am PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, Arizona
I am concerned about the health of my children; we eat fish quite often, usually salmon.

I usually shop at Safeway because it is convenient and I like the house brands, but my husband prefers Albertsons and has been asking me why I don't shop there. This could be a key factor that could change my shopping habits.

# 4,359:
11:14 am PDT, Jun 20, Laura Sierra, Washington
Its almost selling poison.

Safeway has sold reasonabley healthy food for years; this would change peoples opinions about safeway and hurt their reputation as a reliable food source. as it is, i dont shop there, but thats complicated.

# 4,358:
11:02 am PDT, Jun 20, Dian Brown, Indiana
Noted on previous page.

Noted on previous page.

# 4,357:
10:50 am PDT, Jun 20, Janet Black, Washington
Farming salmon is bad for the environment. I won't buy salmon unless it says it is wild.

Many people may not know orcare about the difference but I think companies should try to be ethical and sell good products.

# 4,356:
10:36 am PDT, Jun 20, David Wallis, Washington
FARM SALMON HAS NO GOOD OMEGA 3 OILS. ONLY WILD SALMON DOES. I WILL NOT BUY FARM RAISED FISH. I AM A SAFEWAY CARD HOLDER AND I HAVE CARDS FOR OTHER STORES.

FARM SALMON IS NOT HEALTHY AS NATURAL SALMON. THE U.S. IS OVERWEIGHT AND UNHEALTHY. YOUR STORE CAN DO ITS PART IN HELPING PEOPLE LIVE HEALTHIER LIVES.

# 4,355:
10:32 am PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
I only buy wild caught Salmon in season. I am very concerned about reports of the health of the fish in fish farms, their impact on wild fish populations when they escape as well as help implications for the people who eat them.

Please do not support this dangerous enterprise.

# 4,354:
10:31 am PDT, Jun 20, Lynne Masters-lee, Georgia
If the farmed salmon isn't safe for consumption, then we should either stop farming it, or change the farming procedures to make the salmon safe.

If its not safe for consumption, it shouldn't be on the shelves.

# 4,353:
10:24 am PDT, Jun 20, Lynn Thompson, Washington
Safeway's environmental and health concerns leaves a lot to be desired at best. Any doubt about that, take a tour of one of their warehouse facilities.

The sale of wild Salmon is not as profitable. DOES SAFEWAY CARE???????????

# 4,352:
10:20 am PDT, Jun 20, Cindi Seal, Mississippi
Farmed salmon has been shown to be too risky.

Do it the safe way, Safeway!

# 4,351:
10:15 am PDT, Jun 20, Name not displayed, California
I will not buy any product, nautral or otherwise, which has been proven to be a threat to my family. I now go out of my way to shop for salmon at Trader Joe or Costco, where wild caught salmon is readlly available.

It is an observable fact to me that each time I go elsewhere, I develop new, non going to Safeway habitss. I also am adamant in telling my friennds to boycott farmed salmon, and find it unconscionable that Safeway cares to little about the health of families who shop there that they continue to sell it!

Copyright © 2008 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved