my care2
make a difference
We, the Undersigned, endorse the following petition:

Let Palestinian Film Compete for Oscar

Target: Frank Pierson, President, Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences
Sponsor: Brooke Biggs
  • Signatures: 838
  • Goal: 5,000
  • Deadline: 12-30-2003
Ask the Academy to use its discretion to allow the Palestinian film "Divine Intervention" to compete for Best Foreign Language film.

Enter your name:
Or log in.
Display in public list as "Anonymous"
Number Date Prefix Name Age Gender City State Country Where are you from?
839 2:10 am PDT, Aug 23 Ms. Srishti Kapoor 19 Female Mumbai   India  
838 2:00 am PDT, Jun 7 Mr. Erik Sjodin 25 Male Gothemburg   Sweden  
837 7:28 pm PDT, Apr 16   Mirelle Bonte 30 Female Berkeley California United States  
836 7:03 am PDT, Mar 24 Ms. Sahar Hijazi 16 Female Deir El Assad   Israel  
835 2:53 pm PST, Feb 13   Tatiana Costa 33 Female Sao Paulo   Brazil  
834 9:12 pm PST, Feb 11   Ron Goodman 56 Male Nampa Idaho United States  
833 10:21 am PST, Feb 11   Adem Certel 21 Male London   United Kingdom  
832 6:18 pm PST, Jan 23 Mrs. Eleonore Lee 34 Female San Antonio Texas United States I am astounded to read that this is an issue! Divine Intervention was a brilliant film. It is unbelievable to me that simply because it was made in Palestine that it cannot compete. It is beyond absurd and insulting. The film should be judged on merits alone. If anything Palestinian self-expression should be supported.
831 2:43 pm PDT, Oct 24 Mr. Ahmed Safadi 21 Male Gaza   Palestinian Territory, Occupied Palestine
830 11:28 am PDT, Oct 24   Priya Malhotra 30 Female   Armed Forces Americas United Kingdom  
829 12:18 pm PDT, Oct 9   Ehab El-hasan 29 Male State Univ Arkansas United States  
828 6:45 am PDT, Aug 25 Mr. Michel Durieux 61 Male Geneva   Switzerland Geneva Switzerland
827 10:43 am PDT, Jul 24   D White 41 Female Mooresville Indiana United States  
826 6:26 am PDT, May 1   stephanie lessard 28 Female Derry New Hampshire United States  
825 11:54 am PST, Mar 30   Bryan Freehling 39 Male Lahaska Pennsylvania United States  
824 1:12 pm PST, Mar 18 Mr. Nikolai Dragnes 27 Male Oslo   Norway  
823 8:47 am PST, Mar 16   Toni Sokoloski 49 Female Marstons Mills Massachusetts United States  
822 6:23 am PST, Mar 11   Angela Morrow 22 Female Millinocket Maine United States  
821 7:20 am PST, Mar 10   Ahmed Tawfiq 24 Male   Armed Forces Americas Israel  
820 12:39 pm PST, Feb 27   Sumea Muir 47 Female   Armed Forces Americas United Kingdom  
819 4:42 am PST, Feb 27 Ms. kerstin dahlqvist 46 Female hägersten   Sweden  
818 7:35 pm PST, Feb 25   Jennifer Langyher 36 Female New Castle Pennsylvania United States  
817 3:17 pm PST, Feb 23 Mr. Cedric Longet 25 Male Dijon   France France
815 6:26 pm PST, Feb 20   Anna Asbury 30 Female Louisville Kentucky United States  
814 5:20 am PST, Feb 13 Ms. Jeanne Merick 36 Female   Minnesota Reunion origin france
813 10:28 pm PST, Jan 28   Ann Shirazi 0 Female NYC New York United States New York City
812 8:59 pm PST, Jan 14   Farid de la Ossa 30 Male Chicago Illinois United States  
811 8:17 pm PST, Jan 11   Melissa Mobeck 17 Female Hoquiam Washington United States  
810 6:35 am PST, Jan 8   Chandra Patel 71 Male Bristol Tennessee United States  
809 12:31 pm PST, Dec 20 Ms. Donna Hodsdon-Trips 44 Female New Plymouth Idaho United States  
808 10:06 pm PST, Dec 18   Earth Indigo 35 Female Alger Michigan United States  
807 3:23 pm PST, Dec 13   Michael Daniel Neary 30 Male Rochester New York United States  
806 8:01 am PST, Dec 8 Ms. Brenda Schenk 37 Female Hoquiam Washington United States Hoquiam, WA.
805 10:28 pm PST, Dec 7   Kailey Freeman 20 Female Eugene Oregon United States  
804 7:21 pm PST, Dec 5   Anonymous 44 Female   Armed Forces Americas United Kingdom  
803 7:02 am PST, Dec 5   Julie Salvatore 30 Female Lake Mary Florida United States  
802 2:43 am PST, Dec 5   Steve Dale 44 Male Frankston Victoria   Australia Australia
801 1:47 am PST, Dec 5   Kayla May 17 Female Imperial Bch California United States  

Let Palestinian Film Compete for Oscar

The Palestinian film "Divine Intervention" will not be eligible to compete for the Best Foreign Language Film in this year's Oscar race -- despite the fact the film won the international critic's ward at Cannes -- because The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences does not recognize Palestine as a nation.

Let's be clear on this: the film is not barred from competition because the United States does not recognize Palestine (it does to a certain extent, maintaining diplomatic relations separate from its Israeli ties). The film is barred because The Academy does not recognize Palestine as a nation.

The Academy uses the UN list of recognized nations to determine eligibility, but it also reserves the right to use its own discretion to make exceptions. For example, "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" is a Taiwanese film (it won in 2000), but the UN does not recognize Taiwan as an independent nation. So in other words, you're a country if the Academy says you're a country. That's a pretty big political-cultural stick to wield.

Tell the Academy to use one standard for all films and to stop this unfair discrimination against Palestinian artists.

Note: This Let Palestinian Film Compete for Oscar petition was submitted by Brooke Biggs. ThePetitionSite.com is a free service provided to help concerned citizens rally support for issues they believe in. The opinions expressed by this petition do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of ThePetitionSite.com or Care2.com. There is no express or implied endorsement of this petition nor any newsletter offers (except those from Care2.com) by Care2.com, Inc, ThePetitionSite.com, or our sponsors. If you believe this system is being abused, please contact customer support.

Questions about this petition? Contact the petition sponsor: Brooke Biggs.
Questions about thePetitionSite.com? Visit our FAQ Page.

Copyright © 2010 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved